In "Five is the Magic Number for US Treasuries," Karen Ward, chief market strategist for EMEA at JPMorgan Asset Management, argues that the 10-year Treasury yield, which just passed 5% for the first time since 2007, cannot sustainably go much higher. Her case rests on the Fed offsetting government spending. I agree on this, but only in the case that inflation falls, and with current monetary and fiscal policy pulling against each other, I'm somewhat doubtful.
The Fed is focused on inflation, and as they should be considering since 2020 we really haven't gotten it to a steady rate. At Kevin Warsh's September press conference, he stated that "inflation is too high and has been for too long," and the committee voted unanimously to raise rates. The higher rates serve as a brake for the US economy since we need fewer people borrowing right now to hopefully cool inflation. While a great idea, the problem is that fiscal policy is pushing the gas at the same time. No pun is intended considering the concern of gas prices for the average consumer… Our current fiscal policy is spending way too much money and doesn't seem to care about the exponentially rising costs. To back this, Ward mentions that the US deficit is almost 6% of GDP, which is unheard of in a strong economy, and the costs of the conflict in Iran are likely to make it bigger. On top of this, the administration has floated $5,000 for every household if it wins the midterms, which Ward takes as a sign of an open cheque book. For economists, this idea brings so much fear. Obviously more spending adds to inflation while the Fed is trying to bring it down. That is the tension that I mentioned behind Ward's argument, because her 5% ceiling only holds if the Fed's tightening outweighs the stimulus.
What is also worth mentioning is the discussion Ward brings up around the tech boom in AI. AI-related companies now make up 50% of the S&P 500, and she argues that bonds are a strong hedge if those companies run into trouble. Is that not a concerning stat to anyone? I do agree with the benefits we have received in productivity gains from AI, but Ward points out that those gains would have to be massive to justify yields much higher than 5%. So there are positives, just not enough to push yields up on their own. On top of this, these big tech companies are borrowing at high rates, and with pressure now to borrow less, a halt in their spending would be felt across the market. That is why it is so concerning. So many retirement pensions and financial plans rely on the success of these companies. So what can we take from this? Ward argues against the popular view that bonds no longer diversify and that investors should demand higher yields. I agree with her, because if tech corrects, the Fed would have room to cut and bonds would rally.
All in all, I truly think Ward makes a strong case for 5% being the ceiling on the 10-year yield, but we must consider the entire state of our economic world. With current monetary and fiscal policies counteracting each other, this ceiling is dependent on winning the inflation fight. With Ward bringing up how bonds can hedge against a tech sell-off, I think, as a consumer, it is important to consider that we are reliant on this ceiling holding and not going above. With AI-related companies now making up 50% of the S&P 500, a rise above 5% could cause short-term market declines, which would hurt a lot of people like you and me, especially for people who are hoping to retire or sell their assets. Her article is strong and brings up valuable information about the importance of diversification within portfolios, especially including bonds. Ward gave a great outlook in showing how important the Fed is to the market. With current fiscal policy being so unpredictable nowadays, I'm curious to see where the ceiling stands two months from now. Hopefully, the Fed will continue to do its best to counteract the stimulus from fiscal policy, and we will see the ceiling hold.
So what does this mean for my practice portfolios?
Quick reminder: the Martins and the Clarks are made-up families. I'm a college student running them on live prices for practice, not a portfolio manager, so take this as my read and not advice.
After reading Ward's article, I went back to see how the books are doing. As of Friday's close, the Martins are at about $370K and passing all my allocation rules. The Clarks are at about $382K, but AMD is over my 10% limit. That's a good problem to have, since it's up a lot, but I still need to trim it.
The bigger thing I noticed is the Clarks' AI exposure. From what I can tell, around 45% of the book is in five AI-linked names, and Ward says AI companies are about half of the S&P 500. So if tech takes a hit, the Clarks feel it.
The Martins have a big slice in commercial real estate, mostly REITs. A REIT is a company that owns property, like apartments or warehouses, and pays out most of its income as dividends. REITs tend to move with interest rates. Friday's jobs report, which is the monthly government report on how many jobs the economy added, came in weak at 29,000 vs. 84,000 expected. That lowered the odds of a Fed rate hike, and the Martins' real estate got some relief.
Here's what stood out, though. From what I can tell, neither book has much in bonds right now. Ward's whole point is that bonds can cushion a tech drop, and the Clarks need that most.
My guess, and it's only a guess, is that yields stay around 5% if inflation keeps cooling.
What I'm going to change
Honestly? Not much on the AI side. I'm fine with the AI exposure in the Clarks for the next couple of years, and the Martins too. It's been the story of the market, and I don't want to sit it out.
But I want to keep things calm and know the risk. If tech hits a rough patch, I want something in the books to soften it. That's where bonds come in.
So the plan is to research some bonds I like for both the Clarks and the Martins. I also found BAI, the iShares AI and tech ETF, and it's been a big winner. I want to see how it fits next to the bonds in both books.
AI for growth, bonds for the cushion. I want both. I'll update the books once I've done the work. Simulated practice, not investment advice.
Read the original (Financial Times): https://www.ft.com/content/cf5cf060-401f-43cb-92d1-72afc38b3d3a Cover photo: Kevin Warsh, official portrait, Federal Reserve Board (public domain).
